Three systems, three very different jobs. Pick by where the piece lives and how much it gets handled, not by what sounds most premium.
Carpenters have preferences and they are usually sound, but the three common polish systems really do suit different pieces. Here is the practical difference.
NC (nitrocellulose) lacquer
Fast drying, easy to apply, easy to repair, and the cheapest of the three. It builds a thin film that stays slightly soft, which is why it can be sanded and re-coated without stripping.
- Good for: decorative items, low-traffic furniture, pieces you may want to refinish, tight timelines
- Not for: kitchen shutters, bathroom joinery, anything taking daily abrasion or water
- Life: a few years indoors before it dulls
Melamine
The middle option and the default for most wardrobe and panelling work in homes here. Harder than NC, reasonably scratch resistant, and available in matt through high gloss.
- Good for: wardrobes, panelling, beds, study units, general interior joinery
- Not for: heavy wet areas or surfaces that get chemical cleaning
- Life: comfortably five to eight years on interior work
PU (polyurethane)
Two-component, chemically cured, and far harder than the other two. It gives the deepest finish and takes the most punishment, but it is less forgiving to apply and harder to patch — a damaged area usually means refinishing the whole panel.
- Good for: kitchen shutters, main doors, dining tables, staircases, anything handled daily or exposed to water
- Not for: jobs where cost is the main driver, or where you want easy future touch-ups
- Life: ten years plus on interior work, if applied properly
Water-based coatings
Worth knowing about: low odour, very low VOC, and they do not yellow the way some solvent systems do on pale timber. Useful in occupied homes, hospitals and anywhere the smell of solvent is a problem. Slightly softer than PU, and they need a clean, dust-free application.
A note on matching
Thinner and hardener are not generic. Each system has its own matched reducer, and mixing across brands or using the wrong ratio is the most common cause of a cloudy, slow-curing or sticky finish. Buy the polish, thinner and hardener together.
Quick rule
Wet or heavily handled — PU. Normal interior joinery — melamine. Decorative or temporary — NC. Occupied space with people in it — water-based.